A Guide to Diamond Eternity Rings
The dos and don'ts of finding the perfect diamond eternity band in 2022
We are reader-supported. Buying through any red colored link on our site may earn us commissions. Learn More.
The dos and don'ts of finding the perfect diamond eternity band in 2022
Eternity bands (also known as eternity rings) make meaningful gifts for anniversaries, birthdays and other special celebrations.
The style and setting you choose is mostly based on personal preference, with options ranging from platinum pavé settings like this one from Blue Nile to white gold rings like this eternity band from James Allen. If the eternity ring will be worn next to an engagement or wedding ring, you’ll want to match the style and metal as closely as possible.
We highly recommend purchasing your eternity ring from a reputable vendor like James Allen or Blue Nile to ensure both the diamonds and jewelry are of high quality.
An eternity band, also called an eternity ring or infinity ring, is made of precious metal set with a complete loop of diamonds. With its endless circle of diamonds, an eternity band symbolizes never-ending love.
Why you should trust us
Mike Fried has written hundreds of articles and helped answer more than 30,000 emails from our readers. This has given him a unique perspective on what information truly helps our readers in their quest for finding the perfect diamond engagement ring or piece of jewelry.
Mike is recognized as an industry expert and has been quoted in publications such as Us, People, Page Six, The Next Web and more.
To read more about our process for secret shopping and reviewing companies and additional details about how we operate, check out this article.
Because the diamonds of an eternity ring circle the entire finger, this type of ring offers an extra sparkle. Alternative styles of diamond eternity rings contain diamonds set across the face of the ring only and are known as half-eternity rings.
Eternity rings are often given as anniversary gifts. They’re also given as gifts to celebrate major achievements, milestones such as a major promotion or retirement, the birth of a child or just as a romantic, special gift.
The continuous circle of diamonds on an eternity band symbolizes eternal love, giving eternity bands has a meaning that’s commonly associated with love and relationships. In addition to diamonds, some eternity bands featured colored gemstones which, as noted by the American Gem Society, are increasingly becoming a popular choice as layered jewelry.
Regardless of which style you choose, it’s customary to wear an eternity ring on the left hand ring finger. If the ring is given to you as a milestone anniversary gift, you can wear it between your wedding ring and engagement ring, or in any arrangement that looks attractive to you.
Just like when you’re shopping for an engagement ring, you’ll want to buy an eternity ring from a reliable, reputable jewelry vendor. Based on our extensive experience, we recommend the three following vendors for eternity rings, engagement rings and other fine jewelry:
Blue Nile is one of the world’s largest online diamond retailers, with an unmatched selection of diamond jewelry and loose diamonds alike. Because of Blue Nile’s huge inventory, it’s easy to find an eternity ring or other diamond jewelry that suits your tastes and budget.
In addition to engagement and eternity rings, Blue Nile also offer earrings, wedding rings and other high quality jewelry. Their diamond jewelry is available in a range of metals, from white gold to sterling silver, platinum and others.
In operation for over 17 years, Blue Nile has a strong reputation for high quality diamond and other gemstone jewelry and reliable customer service. Their jewelry craftsmanship is excellent and their prices very competitive, making them a good option for any jewelry purchase. Read our review of Blue Nile to learn more.
Eternity Rings From Blue Nile:
James Allen is another leading online jewelry vendor. Like Blue Nile, they’ve been in business for more than 18 years and have a wealth of experience selling loose diamonds, engagement rings, wedding rings and other fine jewelry.
Advantages of James Allen include the company’s large selection, competitive pricing and use of high resolution online photos and video. This makes it easier to compare items in detail and let you shop with total confidence.
All in all, James Allen is one of the best choices available if you’re searching for a high quality diamond eternity ring at a competitive price. Read our review of James Allen to learn more.
Eternity Rings From James Allen:
Brian Gavin is widely known for offering the best-cut diamonds in the business, meaning their diamonds offer unparalleled brilliance. Their collection is extensive and the quality of many of their pieces is very high, making them a good option if you’re looking for a high-quality ring.
Like Blue Nile and James Allen, Brian Gavin has been in business for decades, with a great reputation for offering high-quality diamond jewelry and excellent value for money. Read our review of Brian Gavin to learn more.
Eternity Rings From Brian Gavin:
A variety of boutique jewelry brands also offer diamond eternity rings, often with extremely high-quality diamonds or other unique features. If you’re searching for something unique and willing to pay extra, please contact us.
As someone who likes to do extensive research before making a decision, I found The Diamond Pro website to be a very valuable resource. In addition to the many great articles and reviews they have, the ability to email specific questions about products/companies they did not review was very helpful. I would definitely recommend to a friend.…see more
There are three important aspects to consider when you’re evaluating the quality and beauty of an eternity ring. The first is the diamonds used in the ring. The second is the setting, while the third is the type of precious metal used to make the band.
The gemstones used in a diamond eternity ring are significantly smaller than the center stone used in an engagement ring. In fact, they’re so much smaller than it’s generally not economical for them to be graded and certified like an engagement ring diamond.
These diamonds are referred to as “melee diamonds” — small diamonds under 0.20 carats in weight that are typically used for decorative purposes, such as on the shank of a band.
For example, the cost of grading and certifying the 14 diamonds used in a typical eternity ring would be about one thousand dollars. This would greatly increase the cost of the ring and make it far less affordable for customers.
Because of this, you won’t get certifications for diamond eternity rings. This makes it important to buy an eternity ring from a reputable vendor like James Allen or Blue Nile, ensuring you get diamonds that are of a high standard.
As smaller diamonds, melee diamonds are significantly more affordable per carat than the larger center diamonds found in most engagement rings. As the GIA explains, they’re a great way to add additional presence to a ring at a modest cost:
“The more diamonds in a ring, the more sparkle it has. Due to their small size, melee diamonds are inexpensive when compared to larger diamond center stones, so they are often generously used in engagement ring designs to add sparkle.” Gemological Institute of America (GIA)
Much of what you’re paying for in an eternity ring is the jewelry’s craftsmanship and style. The way the jewelry is formed and the way the stones are set makes a tremendous difference in the beauty and quality of the ring.
For example, the level of the jeweler’s expertise and the amount of time and care invested in an eternity ring will be much higher with a vendor like James Allen or Blue Nile than a less reliable, less well-known vendor.
When reviewing diamonds yourself, watch for the level of brilliance (the amount the diamonds sparkle and reflect white light). You’ll also want to check that the diamonds are eye clean (this means they don’t have any glaring, visible blemishes).
To evaluate color, check that the diamonds appear white in relation to the setting. With a yellow gold setting, the diamonds can be less white than what’s necessary with a white gold setting.
Eternity rings come in various total carat weights (in the industry, this is shortened to CTW) for every taste and budget.
If you’re not sure where to start or would like assistance in reviewing and comparing diamonds, feel free to contact our experts.
There are four diamond eternity ring styles: prong, channel, bezel and flush. If you want to pair the band with an existing engagement ring or wedding band, try to match the style and metal as closely as you can to your existing rings.
Many diamond eternity rings use prongs for their settings. A prong setting allows more light to reach each diamond. It also increases the number of angles from which light can reach each stone, resulting in greater brilliance.
This 14K white gold eternity ring from James Allen is an example of a prong style setting, while this ring from Blue Nile uses a pavé setting. The most popular diamond shape for eternity rings is the round diamond, though unique styles are available, such as this Asscher cut eternity ring from Blue Nile.
Like other jewelry, there’s no “best” metal for a diamond eternity ring. Instead, the type and color of metal you choose — typically platinum, white gold, rose gold or yellow gold — is usually based on your personal tastes and preferences.
Eternity rings are designed for everyday wear, meaning the materials used to create them tend to be durable. Both 18K and 14K gold in all colors, as well as platinum, are more than durable enough to be used for an everyday wear eternity band.
Our guide to gold and platinum goes into more detail on the key differences between these two popular metals. You can also learn more about 14K gold here.
Eternity rings are traditionally given as gifts, often to celebrate a major milestone in a marriage or other romantic relationship. For example, it’s become something of a modern tradition to gift an eternity ring on major anniversaries and other significant occasions.
Commonly given for milestone wedding anniversaries (i.e. 5th, 10th, 20th, 25th), eternity bands can also be a gift for:
An eternity ring is traditionally worn on the ring finger of the left hand — the same finger that’s used for an engagement ring and wedding band. With this said, there’s no “right” finger for an eternity ring, meaning you can wear your ring on any finger you like.
By choosing a precious metal that complements the engagement and wedding ring, a diamond eternity ring can add an extra special look to you or your partner’s ring finger.
If you have a large engagement ring and don’t want your eternity ring to clash with it, it’s okay to wear the eternity ring on the middle or ring finger of your right hand.
Which order should you wear your wedding, engagement and eternity rings in?
It’s traditional to wear your wedding ring first on your ring finger, placing it closest to your hand and thus closest to your heart. Then, your engagement ring is worn outside the wedding band, with your eternity ring outside your engagement ring.
This traditional order “frames” or “locks in” the engagement ring on the ring finger of your left hand.
Despite being the traditional order for wedding, engagement and eternity rings, there’s no real rule saying you need to wear your rings this way. It’s also common and totally fine to wear the eternity ring on the ring finger of your right hand.
As we mentioned above, this is a good option if you have a large engagement ring and don’t want three rings weighing down your finger. It’s also a good choice if your engagement ring’s center stone makes it hard to wear the engagement and eternity rings close together.
If you’re not worried about tradition, it’s perfectly fine to wear your wedding band, engagement ring and eternity ring in any order that feels comfortable to you.
Since eternity rings go on the left ring finger, it’s easy to determining the right size by using the person’s existing wedding ring or engagement ring.
To find the size of an existing wedding or engagement ring, measure the inner diameter of the ring, then compare it to a ring sizing chart. You can also wrap a thin piece of paper around the person’s finger, then mark the spot where the paper overlaps with a pen or pencil.
It’s also possible to measure someone’s ring size using a printable ring sizer. Finally, if you’re not confident measuring someone’s ring size on your own, you can go to a jewelry store for a professional measurement.
If you’re unable to obtain the size and want the ring to be a surprise, consider having a close friend or family member of the person you’re buying the ring for sneak the information.
Although it’s not traditional, some people choose to give an eternity ring as an engagement ring in place of a conventional diamond ring. It’s also becoming increasingly common to present an eternity ring during the proposal, then choose a traditional engagement ring together.
There are no absolute “rules” of giving an engagement ring, meaning you can give any ring you and your partner will feel comfortable with. If you think your partner would prefer an eternity ring to a conventional engagement ring, don’t let tradition stop you from doing what you want.
Despite their similar design, eternity rings come in a range of different styles and diamond carat weights, including many rings suitable for use as engagement rings. These include:
Unlike most engagement rings, infinity rings are quite complicated to resize. Because of this, it’s vital that you know your partner’s ring size before you propose using an infinity ring. Use the tips above or in our ring sizing guide to make sure you buy a ring that’s a comfortable fit.
Dating back to ancient Egypt, eternity rings — although not always in the diamond and precious metal form we’re familiar with today — have likely been worn for almost 4,000 years.
Notable eternity rings have popped up countless times throughout history and have been worn by many celebrities and royalty:
To purchase a beautiful diamond eternity ring that will match the style and personality of your someone special, look for one from a reputable vendor like James Allen or Blue Nile.
Can’t decide on the right eternity ring? Need help identifying a ring that uses high-quality metal, diamonds or other gemstones? Contact our experts at any time for assistance in reviewing and assessing eternity rings and other high-quality diamond jewelry.
Eternity rings are designed to symbolize love and commitment, with the continuous circle of diamonds symbolizing continuous, eternal love. This originated in Ancient Egypt, with simple carved rings showing up in Old Egyptian hieroglyphics and archaeological sites.
This is another modern custom that’s become particularly common in the last decade. Just like giving an eternity ring as an engagement ring (which is one of the alternatives to the traditional diamond engagement ring that some people prefer), it’s totally okay to wear an eternity ring instead of a traditional wedding ring. In fact, many people enjoy the extra sparkle an eternity ring offers.
Eternity rings can usually be resized. However, the process is more complicated than it is for a typical diamond engagement ring and often requires quite a large change to the way the ring looks, meaning it’s best to avoid having to resize an eternity ring if possible.
As eternity rings contain a continuous circle of diamonds, resizing a ring often requires removing one or several of the diamonds. To do this, a jeweler might need to replace the removed section of the ring with a blank, unadorned piece of metal that doesn’t feature any diamonds.
Sizing an eternity ring down is usually a simpler process. To do this, the jeweler will remove one or several of the diamonds from the ring, then take out any excess metal and join the two ends of the ring together again.
Because resizing an eternity ring is quite a complicated process, many jewelers will recommend alternatives, such as adding sizing beads to the inside of the ring. This can often make a slightly loose ring more comfortable and prevent it from sliding around on the finger.
Please enter your email address to receive your personal one-time use unique coupon code:
Before you buy a diamond, get personal buying advice from industry veterans. We'll help you get the best diamond for the money.
DISCLAIMER: We don't use your email for marketing. Period.
A diamonds' price is determined primarily by the 4 Cs of the diamond. On the wholesale level, diamond prices are first based on a diamond shape and s
Over the last ten years I have secret shopped thousands of engagement ring retailers (usually with Annie, or another one of our diamond consultants).
1ct round cut petite side-stone diamond ring in yellow gold from Blue Nile A wide range of 1 carat diamonds exist both in online markets and local
Please enter your email address to receive your personal one-time use unique coupon code:
Here is your coupon code: GFDSF3GF