Our Ultimate Christmas Gift Buying Guide for Jewelry

Bottom Line Recommendation:

This Christmas, show your love and appreciation for the special people in your life. Whether it’s your fiancé, wife, mom or best friend, a beautiful piece of jewelry makes for an unforgettable gift. 

Our Christmas jewelry gift guide below includes bracelets, earrings, pendants and rings from highly recommended vendors. Look through the suggestions to see what matches your loved ones’ personalities the best. For last Christmas, I actually bought my girlfriend a unique looking scatter V diamond necklace from Blue Nile.

Most importantly, we recommend purchasing your Christmas jewelry from a reputable vendor. For colored gemstone jewelry, consider Blue Nile, Leibish & Co. and James Allen. For diamond jewelry, choose Blue Nile, James Allen, or Brian Gavin. 

Finding a meaningful Christmas gift is well worth the effort. Rather than a gift that they’ll forget in a year, a piece of jewelry will be remembered and cherished for years to come.

When selecting jewelry for a loved one, take into account their personal style. Do you often see them with a colorful necklace or a pair of dangly earrings? Do they prefer bracelets or pendants? Choose something unique to make them feel extra special.

Our guide includes over 40 Christmas jewelry gift ideas. For mom, grandma or your girlfriend, choose holiday jewelry that will become a keepsake. From necklaces to bracelets, there’s something here for every style.

An extra perk of buying online? Avoiding the holiday crowds and busy shopping centers.

Diamond Jewelry Christmas Gifts For Women

If you’re looking for jewelry Christmas gift ideas for her this year, very little comes close to diamond jewelry. Diamonds make for a stunning, timeless gift, perfect for any woman in your life. Look through the suggestions below for an unforgettable jewelry gift for your wife, girlfriend, mother or daughter.

1) Diamond Bracelets

Bracelets are beautiful holiday jewelry that can be worn all year long. Styles range from tennis bracelets to gemstone designs made of sapphires, rubies, and emeralds. You can find modern bracelet styles, like this bangle, that make great jewelry for your wife for Christmas or traditional pieces like this mini diamond bar for someone who prefers a classic look.

Looking for timeless Christmas jewelry? Consider a tennis bracelet with 54 diamonds like this one from Blue Nile or a bar bracelet with 13 diamonds that’s also available on Blue Nile.

Another Diamond bracelet Christmas gift idea:

• Diamond and Sapphire Bracelet from James Allen 

2) Diamond Earrings

Give her something unforgettable to unwrap this Christmas with a stunning set of diamond earrings. Earrings are a perfect way to show your love and appreciation for your partner, mother, or grandmother.

From studs to hoops and floral patterns, you can handpick a pair that matches her style. You can choose a simple pair for everyday wear or a more unique set for special occasions. Online vendors like Blue Nile and James Allen offer options for you to design your own earrings as gifts for her. The best part about diamond earrings is that they can be worn with outfits on many festive occasions, such as an upcoming New Year’s party or graduation.

The earrings we suggest are from the best diamond vendors in the industry. Their jewelry and settings are made with precision and care.

Diamond earring Christmas gift ideas:

• Wire Basket Stud Earrings from James Allen
• Floral Stud Earrings in 14K Gold from Blue Nile
• Mini Diamond Pavé Hoops from Blue Nile

3) Diamond Necklaces and Pendants

Diamond necklaces are holiday jewelry often given as a symbol of love, particularly eternal love. A diamond pendant is special because it’s worn close to the heart. Consider designing a pendant for your partner this Christmas.

Choose a solitaire necklace featuring one diamond or other styles with more diamonds, like halo necklaces, three-stone necklaces, and unique designs. You can choose 14K or 18K gold in colors such as rose, yellow, and white. You can also design a pendant with platinum, but it costs more and usually isn’t necessary for a pendant or necklace.

Think about getting a heart pendantor a six prong pendant this Christmas. These pendants are designed to allow maximum light to pass through the diamond, providing plenty of brilliance and sparkle.

Necklaces are perfect Christmas gifts for a girlfriend, daughter, wife, or any other special woman in your life.

Pendant and necklace Christmas gift ideas:

• Petite Diamond Cross Pendant from Blue Nile
• Princess Cut Pendant in Yellow Gold from Blue Nile
• A Three-stone Drop Pendant from Blue Nile

4) Diamond Rings

Diamond rings aren’t just for engagement. They make stunning gifts for other celebrations too, like Christmas. With styles like unique halo rings and twist diamond eternity bands, your gift is likely to become a keepsake.

Consider an eternity ring to celebrate an important anniversary or other relationship milestone. Or choose a fun cocktail diamond ring to bring a festive spirit to her jewelry collection.

Diamond ring Christmas gift ideas:

• Marquise and Dot Diamond Ring from Blue Nile
• Micro Pavé Diamond Ring from Blue Nile

Christmas Gemstone Gifts

Want a unique, colorful alternative to a diamond? Opt for a gemstone like an opal, ruby, emerald or sapphire. These gemstones are natural stones and have a unique color that gives them their beauty and appeal. Opal is a birthstone and is usually black or white. Rubies are from the corundum family and have a red hue that varies from faint to vivid. Emerald is green but can have other undertones like yellow and blue. Sapphires come in a variety of colors but are most often blue gemstones. 

The best news about gemstone gifts? There are hundreds of stones and color variations, so you can truly design something that is one-of-a-kind for your partner. You can create gemstone rings, earrings, necklaces, bracelets, and more on James Allen or Blue Nile. Choose from yellow gold, white gold, rose gold, and platinum settings. Gemstones are perfect for holiday jewelry that will stand out and be a prized possession.

Gemstones are eye-catching and often cost less than diamonds. Consider his or her birthstone, or their favorite color when designing a truly personalized piece of jewelry.

A great service, they really made the purchasing process easy. I would recommend to anyone. Veronika was super helpful and responsive. She gives you confidence that you are making the right decision. My partner was VERY happy with the final product – what more can you ask? The diamond guides are very interesting and useful too.

…see more

Will Marsden

Dec 25, 2022

Excellent info and education about Diamonds. Unbiased opinions and advice. Highly recommend the content on their site before making a Diamond purchase. They even offer one on one service via email for advice and recommendation.

…see more

EV User

Feb 1, 2023

5) Gemstone Bracelets

Add color to her wrist with a sparkly gemstone bracelet. Choose a single gemstone or a multi-colored design.

Bracelets can be made with almost every gemstone—from emeralds to sapphires.

Gemstone bracelet Christmas gift ideas:

• Freshwater Pearl and White Topaz Bangle from Blue Nile
• Vintage Bracelet (with Emeralds, Sapphires or Rubies) from Blue Nile
• Aquamarine Bezel Set Bracelet from Blue Nile

6) Gemstone Earrings

Colored gemstones earrings are bound to draw attention. The vivid colors add character and personality to any outfit.

Styles and shapes for earrings vary greatly, from topaz drop earrings to magnolia ruby earrings.

Gemstone earring Christmas gift ideas:

• Amethyst Cushion Studs from Blue Nile
• Ruby Rose Stud Earrings from Blue Nile
• Tourmaline Drop Earrings from Leibish & Co.

7) Gemstone Necklaces and Pendants

Colorful pendants are standouts in the world of Christmas gifts. The dash of blue, green or pink will steal the show with its remarkable color.

Choose a simple style like an aquamarine cushion cut pendant or a sapphire solitaire pendant. Or select a design that’s more intricate like an amethyst halo pendant.

Gemstone pendant and necklace Christmas gift ideas:

• Sapphire and Diamond Necklace from James Allen
• Amethyst Halo Pendant from Blue Nile
• Blue Topaz Halo Pendant from Blue Nile

8) Gemstone Rings

Any ring, especially a colored gemstone ring, represents passion and beauty. Design one that will make him or her feel extra special.

Choose a birthstone or favorite color to create your rings.

Gemstone ring Christmas gift ideas:

• Vintage Emerald Ring from James Allen
• Oval Ruby Halo Ring from Blue Nile
• Green Tourmaline and Diamond Band Ring from Leibish & Co.

Where to Purchase Your Christmas Jewelry

The most important recommendation we can give you when purchasing jewelry for Christmas gifts is to choose a highly reputable vendor. Rather than ending up with jewelry that’s of inferior quality, you’ll have a gift that’s high-quality and can last for generations.

The vendors below offer beautiful diamond gifts and gemstone options at excellent prices. Our years of experience in the industry have given us a consistent pulse on which vendors you can trust.

All jewelry is made with high-quality metal and stones. Not only will you end up with beautiful, durable jewelry, but you’ll get it at an excellent price, too.

James Allen

• Focuses on the customer experience
• Offers appealing prices
• Provides photo imagery to help you select the best diamonds and gemstones
• Read our James Allen review here

Blue Nile

• Emphasizes remarkable quality and jewelry settings
• Offers the largest online inventory of diamonds
• Maintains an inventory of diamond and colored gemstone designs
• Check out our full Blue Nile review

Brian Gavin Diamonds

• Offers super-ideal cuts with the “Brian Gavin Signature” Hearts & Arrows collection
• Features some of the best cut diamonds in the world
• Read our Brian Gavin Diamonds review here

Leibish & Co.

• Maintains an extensive inventory of gemstone and colored diamond jewelry
• Creates their jewelry with high-quality metal and settings
• Read our full review of Leibish & Co. here

Why You Shouldn’t Purchase Substandard Jewelry For Christmas

Many jewelers offer seemingly great gifts for holidays like Christmas. Their advertisements target a particular line of jewelry or even specific items. While these companies may seem reliable, the jewelry is often poorly made. The pieces are often crafted quickly or without the best tools, materials, and talent. 

We recommend steering clear of sterling silver jewelry and jewelry made with base metals like copper, brass, and aluminum. These metals won’t be nearly as durable or long-lasting. Instead, look for fine jewelry made of 14K or 18K gold. 

You also want to avoid paying high prices for costume jewelry and fashion jewelry that may have simulated stones or gemstones that aren’t rare. High-quality jewelry has real gemstones and diamonds. Real gemstones look beautiful and last much longer. 

In other words, if you’re not careful, you can purchase substandard jewelry that won’t maintain its beauty or value. Although the price tag is tempting, you’re not getting nearly the value of what you’re paying.

That’s why we recommend only choosing high-quality jewelry from reputable vendors (see our list above). By purchasing something from a trusted vendor, you’ll give a remarkable and lasting Christmas gift.

FAQs about Christmas Jewelry

What jewelry should I get my girlfriend for Christmas?

If you’re not ready to propose, you can get your girlfriend a pair of earrings, a pendant, or a bracelet for Christmas. Choose from diamonds and gemstones to design a unique gift that will show her how much she means to you.

Does jewelry go on sale after Christmas?

Gold and silver jewelry tends to go on sale after Christmas as stores try to offload their holiday inventory. However, vendors might offer discounts on everything from rings and earrings to necklaces and bracelets even before Christmas to give you a chance to have something pretty under the tree. Otherwise, you might consider a New Year’s gift for your partner or purchasing jewelry after Christmas to save for an upcoming milestone like Valentine’s Day or your anniversary.

Is a ring a good Christmas present?

A ring makes for a great Christmas present if it’s an engagement ring for your girlfriend or a ring for your wife. Eternity bands are great for milestone anniversary years and gemstone cocktail rings are fun and special. Giving a ring to your girlfriend when it’s not an engagement ring is bound to send mixed messages.

Email Our Experts For Assistance With Christmas Jewelry

Our experts know how to tell a stunning diamond from a mediocre one. They know when a reader is getting a great deal and when they’re getting ripped off.

By contacting our experts, you’ll get one-on-one advice on what diamonds, gemstones, and jewelry to choose—based on your tastes. If you’re looking for a timeless diamond pendant for under $1,000, we’ll help you find the best one. If you want to design an antique engagement ring, we’ll help you design one of your dreams. Above all, we are committed to helping you find long-lasting, beautiful jewelry at the best price.

No matter which pendant, ring, bracelet or necklace you put under the tree, know that a thoughtful gift is what matters most. Jewelry gifts represent love, care and appreciation. And your loved one will think of you every time they wear it.

For assistance in choosing diamond or gemstone jewelry, email our experts.

Here are some other diamond jewelry gift topics to browse:

• Diamond jewelry gift ideas for mom on Mother’s Day
• Diamond jewelry gift ideas for her on Valentine’s Day
• What to consider when buying a wedding band or ring
• Anniversary gift ideas for your wife (1, 5, 10, 20, 25, 30+ years)
• Wedding jewelry gift ideas for the bride
• Diamond jewelry “push present” gift ideas
• Diamond promise ring ideas for her 
• What to consider when buying gemstone jewelry

James Allen James Allen is the leader in online diamond sales. Their imaging technology is the same as inspecting a diamond with a jeweler's loupe. They have the largest exclusive loose diamond inventory online and fantastic prices. They also have the nicest collection of lab created diamonds online.

Click to Visit

What we love about them:

• No questions asked returns within 30 days of shipment. James Allen will send you a paid shipping label to return the ring.
• Lifetime Warranty
• Free International Shipping
• Free prong tightening, repolishing, rhodium plating and cleaning every 6 months
• Provide insurance appraisals
• One free resizing within 60 days of purchase
• Free ring inscriptions
• Best-in-class high quality imagery of all diamonds in stock
• 24/7 Customer Service
• Best-in-class packaging

Blue Nile Blue Nile is the largest and most well known internet jewelry seller. They have a very large exclusive online inventory. Their high quality images are catching up to James Allens' and their prices are amazing.

Click to Visit

What we love about them:

• No questions asked returns within 30 days of shipment. Blue Nile will send you a paid shipping label to return the ring.
• Lifetime Warranty
• Free Shipping
• Free prong tightening, repolishing, rhodium plating and cleaning every 6 months
• Provide insurance appraisal
• One free resizing within the first year of purchase
• High quality images of about half of their diamonds
• 24/7 Customer Service
• 100% credit towards future upgrades (must be at least double in value)
• Best in class fulfillment

About the author

Mike Fried Mike Fried has over 25 years experience in the diamond industry working with Leo Schachter Diamonds, Moshe Namdar Diamonds, and joining The Diamond Pro in 2007. He is recognized as an industry expert and has been quoted in publications such as Us, People, Page Six, The Next Web and more.