We get commissions for purchases made from our affiliates through links in this article. Learn More.
|Mike Fried|| Overall Score:3|| Price:1|| Selection:3|| Customer Service:5||Pros||Cons||Other Recommended Retailers|
Harry Winston’s name has been synonymous with luxury for longer than I’ve been around. Following his father’s, Jacob, footsteps who opened a jewelry business when immigrated from Ukraine, Harry opened his own business in 1920 with his first store opening up in New York City in 1932.
The jewelry business was always in Harry Winston’s blood. When he was twelve years old, Harry noticed a 2ct Emerald in a pawn shop and bought it for 25 cents. He quickly sold that gem for $800. His business really took root when he managed to acquire Arabella Huntington’s jewelry collection for $1.2 million in 1926.
Harry Winston redesigned pieces for all the gems that were in the Huntington collection (mostly from major Parisian jewelers). From the start, his craftsmanship and eye for detail were easily recognizable. His stature grew steadily as he managed to acquire many notable diamonds. His first major acquisition was the Jonker diamond, a 726ct rough diamond.
The crown jewel in his collection was the Hope Diamond. The Hope Diamond is 45.52ct and has a storied past. The diamond has an incredible deep blue hue. Owned by various Kings and Sultans, bouncing around European royalty and others, Harry got his hands on it in 1947. Harry Winston owned it for about a decade before donating it to the Smithsonian who describes it as “the most famous diamond in the world.”
Harry Winston’s name is even mentioned in the song “Diamonds are a Girl’s Best Friend” from the musical “Gentlemen Prefer Blondes.”
Harry Winston was giving jewelry pieces to celebrities for the red carpet back before it was cool. Liz Taylor was often seen wearing a stunning jewelry designed by Harry Winston. The most iconic was her necklace that included the 69.42ct Taylor-Burton diamond that Harry cut himself.
Madonna rocked out on stage at the 1991 Academy Awards weighed down by $20 million of Harry Winston diamonds. J-Lo, Helen Mirren, Amal Clooney and Natalie Portman are just a few others that walked the red carpet wearing Harry Winston masterpieces.
Following Harry Winston’s death in 1978, there was a protracted legal battle over who would run the company. After many years his son Ronald, along with Fenway Partners, bought out his brother Bruce for $54.
They currently have 40 locations around the world, covering four continents. Their pieces can also be found in many high end boutique jewelers as well.
I was recently in Houston meeting with some folks in the industry and decided to do a little secret shopping. One of them mentioned that Harry Winston recently opened up a shop in the Luxurious River Oaks District. I had a little free time, so I hopped in an uber and headed over there. I called ahead and was surprised that appointments weren’t necessary.
Even from the outside, you can tell this is no ordinary shop. The building reeks elegance even from the outside. I was definitely self conscious of how I was dressed (my luggage was lost the day before and I was definitely not wearing my finest duds). I have done quite a bit of secret shopping and have found that some of the more upscale places tend to be a bit snooty if you come into the store “underdressed.”
Upon entering, I can see that the inside was just as elegant as the outside. I was very impressed with the ambiance of the place. What also impressed, and surprised, me was their attitude. As I mentioned, many of the upscale places tend to look down on some people. I did not get that feeling at all. The people were downright friendly.
I sat with a sales consultant named Ahmpi. She was a gem to work with. She listened to what I was looking for and made a genuine effort to find the right rings for me. Her knowledge of diamonds and jewelry was also very apparent. Normally I have to bite my tongue as I listen to inaccurate facts about diamonds. Usually this isn’t meant as deception from the jewelers, just that your typical shop assistant doesn’t have the education or experience to really help you buy a diamond.
Ahmpi seemed quite knowledgeable. It was more about what she didn’t say than what she did say. It was clear to me that she had the underlying knowledge and experience when she talked about what type of diamonds she recommends and why. I may not agree (for example, we don’t agree with their feelings on color and clarity as we explain in our articles), but she knew what she was talking about and it was just a difference in opinion; something I respect.
I asked them to see some options for round diamond engagement rings in the $40,000 range. I was shown three choices. The first one was a beautiful halo ring with a 1.13ct F VVS1 from The One collection. The other two were solitaires. One was 1.54ct D VS1 and the last was 1.22ct E VVS1. The 1.22 was in the HW logo collection. All three diamonds were absolutely stunning. They brilliance was very noticeable and the craftsmanship on the rings were superb.
Most people actually buying at Harry Winston are probably looking at diamonds in the 5 carat range, but I’m guessing most of our readers here are looking to spend less than half a million dollars on a ring.
Here is where the wheels start coming off the bus. I get that Harry Winston is a brand whose mere name adds value to the purchase. But I never thought that $40,000 wouldn’t be enough to get in the door there. Technically they had something for me, but the value was ridiculous.
Let’s start with the halo ring which cost $37,000. Let’s get the obvious out of the way. Both the diamond and the ring were fantastic. The craftsmanship on the ring was superb and the diamond was very brilliant. But there is nothing particularly special about the setting they put it in. In fact, Brian Gavin Diamonds has a gorgeous halo setting that is very similar. As we explain in our BGD review, Brian Gavin cuts the most brilliant diamonds I have ever seen. So you can pair that ring with this stunning 1.17 F VS1 Black by Brian diamond and get a virtually identical looking ring for 55% cheaper.
Two points I should make. One is that we aren’t talking about comparing higher quality to lower. Brian Gavin’s craftsmanship and diamond quality are every bit as luxurious as that ring from Harry Winston was. Also, it’s not just about saving money. It’s about getting the best bang for your buck. You are sacrificing big time on what you can get.
Here is a stunning 2.07ct Black by Brian diamond. You can buy this diamond with the same setting and it still comes in cheaper than Harry Winston halo. That means you are sacrificing almost half the size for the Harry Winston name. That just doesn’t add up to me.
Let’s talk about the 1.54 D VS1 which cost $54,000. This was in a fairly straightforward setting that virtually every higher end jeweler has. You can go with this superb 1.53 D VS1 Black by Brian and it will cost you about half of what the Harry Winston ring will cost you.
There are two-tiers of Harry Winston customers. For anyone spending less than $1,000,000 on a ring, it just doesn’t make sense. You end up sacrificing so much in terms of size, you’ll end up with a ring that looks underwhelming.
For those spending more than $1,000,000, you’ll end up with a beautiful ring. But you are still paying an enormous premium for the brand name. You can get an even more intricate piece with even higher quality or larger diamonds in it for the same price. That’s up to you to decide.
Before you buy a diamond, get personal buying advice from industry veterans. We'll help you get the best diamond for the money.
DISCLAIMER: We don't use your email for marketing. Period.
We are a team of diamond experts who will teach you to identify scams and avoid spending money on features you can't see. Tell us as much information as possible to help us help you (ie, budget, preferences, etc)Why do we do this?
DISCLAIMER: We don't use your email for marketing. Period.
Here is your coupon code: GFDSF3GF