8 Christmas Jewelry Gifts She’ll Treasure

Buying jewelry for Christmas can feel harder than it should be. You want something she’ll actually wear, not something that sits in a drawer until it gets regifted. You also don’t want to guess wrong on style or spend more than you need to.

I went through Brilliant Earth’s holiday and gifts for her collections and picked eight pieces I’d stand behind. They cover necklaces, earrings, a bracelet, and a charm, and they range from $225 to $1,495. Whatever your budget looks like this year, there’s something here that works.

Bottom Line Up Front

If she wears earrings every day, start with the Taylor Lab Diamond Huggie Earrings ($495) or the 2mm Huggie Perfect Hoop Earrings ($225).

Want something with more presence? The Petite Lab Diamond Tennis Bracelet ($995) is one of the most versatile pieces on this list.

If you want to go bigger, the Perfect Solitaire Lab Diamond Pendant ($1,495) is a piece she can wear for the rest of her life.

Now let’s get into all eight.

Here’s What We’ll Cover:

• Necklace Gifts
• Earring Gifts
• Bracelet Gifts
• Charm Gifts
• In Summary
• FAQ

Necklace Gifts

A necklace is a safe bet for Christmas. She can layer it, wear it alone, or save it for a special outfit. These three cover very different styles and prices.

Hydrangea Bouquet Pendant

Starting at $395

Available in: Silver, 14K Yellow Gold

This pendant clusters four stones together. A London Blue topaz, a sapphire, an aquamarine, and a diamond all sit close, so the piece reads as one design instead of four separate gems.

The silver version is one of the more affordable options on this list, and it still uses genuine gemstones and a genuine diamond. Brilliant Earth’s own design team in San Francisco created this piece.

This is a good pick if you want color without going bold, or if you know her birth month falls in September or March.

Devon Lightweight Paperclip Chain Necklace (Small)

Starting at $525

Available in: 14K Yellow Gold, 14K White Gold

Paperclip chains have been everywhere the last few years, and there’s a reason for that. The flat, elongated links catch light differently than a round curb or rope chain, which gives the necklace a more modern look.

This small-link version is lightweight, so it layers well with other necklaces without adding bulk. It also works fine on its own if she prefers a simple, everyday chain.

If she already owns a pendant or charm she loves, this chain gives her a new way to wear it.

Perfect Solitaire Lab Diamond Pendant (1 ct. tw.)

$1,495

Available in: 18K Yellow Gold, 18K White Gold

This is about as classic as a diamond necklace gets. One lab grown diamond, 1 carat total weight, set in minimal metal on an adjustable chain. No distractions from the stone itself.

Brilliant Earth’s Perfect Collection is built around precision cutting and a simple setting, so the diamond does the work instead of the design around it. Lab grown diamonds are chemically and visually identical to natural diamonds. The difference is price, which means a solitaire this size costs less than a natural diamond version of the same carat weight and quality.

If she’s the kind of person who wears one meaningful piece and nothing else, this is the necklace.

Earring Gifts

Earrings are the easiest jewelry gift to get right. There’s no ring size to guess and no bracelet length to measure. These three cover a wide range of price and style.

2mm Huggie Perfect Hoop Earrings

$225

Available in: 14K Yellow Gold, 14K White Gold

These are small, tube-style hoops that sit close to the ear. At 13mm tall and 2mm wide, they’re noticeable without being loud, which makes them one of the more wearable hoop styles out there.

They’re also lightweight enough that she can forget she has them on, which is exactly what you want from an everyday earring. They work dressed up or dressed down, and they stack well if she wears multiple piercings.

At $225 in solid 14K gold, this is one of the more accessible entry points on this list.

Taylor Lab Diamond Huggie Earrings (1/3 ct. tw.)

$495

Available in: 14K Yellow Gold

These huggie earrings pair a round lab grown diamond on top with pavé-set lab grown diamonds running along the hoop. Total weight comes to 1/3 ct. tw., enough to catch light without looking oversized.

The huggie style hugs close to the earlobe, so it’s comfortable enough to wear all day and sleep in if she wants to. It also looks put together with a blazer or casual with a t-shirt, which is what makes it a good everyday piece rather than a special-occasion one.

This is my top pick on this list if you want something she’ll actually reach for every morning.

Sol Starburst Diamond Stud Earrings (1/10 ct. tw.)

$650

Available in: 14K Yellow Gold

Instead of one diamond per ear, these studs spread a pair of diamonds in a starburst shape. That design catches more light than a single solitaire stud because the stones radiate outward instead of sitting in one spot.

These are natural diamonds, which means they meet Brilliant Earth’s Beyond Conflict Free™ standard. That standard covers labor conditions, environmental impact, and community involvement at the mine level, and less than 1% of the world’s natural diamonds qualify for it.

They work well worn alone or stacked with a second pair of studs.

Bracelet Gifts

A bracelet is visible in a way that earrings and necklaces sometimes aren’t, which makes it a strong pick if you want the gift to be noticed right away.

Petite Lab Diamond Tennis Bracelet (1 1/2 ct. tw.)

$995

Available in: 14K Yellow Gold, 14K White Gold

A tennis bracelet is one of the most useful things a woman can own. This one carries 1 1/2 carats total weight of lab grown diamonds set in a slim, low-profile design that circles the entire wrist.

The stones sit small and close together, which gives the bracelet a polished look rather than a chunky one. It fits under a jacket sleeve or on its own, and it works for daily wear instead of sitting in a jewelry box for special occasions only.

Lab grown diamonds are what make a bracelet like this possible under $1,000. A natural diamond tennis bracelet at this same carat weight would cost a good deal more.

Charm Gifts

A charm works well if she already owns a chain or bracelet she loves. It adds something new without asking you to guess a length or a style she doesn’t already wear.

Heart Diamond Charm (1/10 ct. tw.)

$495

Available in: 14K Yellow Gold

This is a solid gold heart with five flush-set natural diamonds across the face and milgrain detail around the edge. Flush settings sit flat against the metal, so the diamonds won’t snag on clothing or scratch during normal wear.

The bail is built to clip onto most chain styles without any tools, so she can add it to a necklace she already wears every day or start a new one with it. That flexibility is what makes a charm feel like a real gift instead of a last-minute add-on.

At $495 in solid 14K gold with natural diamonds, this is the kind of charm that actually gets worn.

In Summary

Christmas jewelry doesn’t have to be complicated. Figure out what she already wears, pick something in that same style, and buy from a store that stands behind what it sells.

Brilliant Earth’s holiday selection covers a real range here, from a $225 pair of gold hoops to a $1,495 diamond solitaire necklace, with solid options in between. Every piece on this list uses solid gold or silver and genuine diamonds or gemstones. None of them are novelty pieces you’ll want to replace next year.

If you’re still deciding between a few options, Brilliant Earth has 40+ stores across the US where you can see pieces in person before you buy. You can also book a virtual appointment if there isn’t one near you.

FAQ

What is a good Christmas jewelry gift budget?

There’s no single right number. Brilliant Earth has pieces starting around $225, like the 2mm Huggie Perfect Hoop Earrings, and strong options up to $1,495 for a diamond necklace. Pick a price that’s comfortable for you, then look for solid gold or silver and genuine stones rather than plated metal.

What jewelry should I get her for Christmas if I’m not sure what she likes?

Go with something she can wear every day rather than something trendy. Huggie earrings, a simple diamond pendant, or a tennis bracelet all work because they go with almost anything. Think about whether she already wears gold or silver, and match that instead of guessing.

Are lab grown diamonds a good choice for a Christmas gift?

Yes. Lab grown diamonds are chemically and visually identical to natural diamonds. The only real difference is price, since lab grown stones cost less than natural diamonds of the same size and quality. That means you can get more carat weight or a better setting for the same budget.

What is the difference between a huggie earring and a hoop earring?

A huggie sits close to the earlobe with a small, tight profile, while a standard hoop hangs slightly away from the ear. Huggies tend to be more comfortable for daily wear and less likely to snag on hair or clothing.

Can I see Brilliant Earth jewelry in person before buying it as a gift?

Yes. Brilliant Earth has 40+ store locations across the US where you can view pieces in person and talk to a jewelry specialist one on one. Virtual appointments are also available if there isn’t a store near you.

Does Brilliant Earth offer gift wrapping or a return option for Christmas gifts?

Brilliant Earth offers free shipping both ways and a 30-day return policy, along with a lifetime warranty on their jewelry. That gives you room to exchange a piece if the size or style isn’t quite right for her.

About the author

Mike Fried Mike Fried has over 25 years experience in the diamond industry working with Leo Schachter Diamonds, Moshe Namdar Diamonds, and joining The Diamond Pro in 2007. He is recognized as an industry expert and has been quoted in publications such as Us, People, Page Six, The Next Web and more.