James Allen & Blue Nile

This article is a discussion of the history of the retail diamond market and its evolution towards selling online.  If you’re looking for reviews of James Allen & Blue Nile, then click here: Blue Nile Review and James Allen Review.

Before there was Blue Nile

In the classic model of the diamond jewelry supply chain, De Beers sells rough diamonds for cash (Cash on Delivery — no credit allowed) to sightholders (a limited list of diamond polishers with rights to buy rough diamonds directly from De Beers) who manufacture the rough into polished diamonds.  They sell diamonds to local wholesalers who, in turn, sell to local jewelry stores.  This system leads to several disadvantages to the consumer.

Firstly, since De Beers demands of its sightholders cash payment, the sightholders are constantly struggling with cash flow.  They have a commitment of several million dollars approximately every six weeks when De Beers sells its rough diamonds at what it calls “sights” (hence, sightholders.) Most diamond polishers don’t have that kind cash lying around, so they must have a constantly open large line of credit.  Add to that the fact that it takes approximately 3 months to finish manufacturing a box of rough diamonds, and you see that even if the sightholder could miraculously sell all of the diamonds polished from one box on the first day they are available, the sightholder has still added three months of interest payments onto the cost of the diamonds.  And that’s only if their customers pay in cash, which is extremely rare in the diamond business.  Most diamond wholesalers agree to pay in 90 days from the time of their purchase, but on average, these diamond dealers will pay a month or two past their agreed upon time.  And this doesn’t take into consideration the additional month (at least) it will take to send the diamonds for certification.

Another outcome of this cash requirement of De Beers’ is that sightholders are loathe to tie up their diamonds anywhere.  Rarely will a sightholder agree to leave diamonds on a consignment basis with a customer.  Sightholders need to constantly sell to clear out inventory — because whether they like it or not, a new batch of diamonds is always only 6 weeks away that they need to pay for up front.

Sightholders aren’t the only ones with a heavy burden of pressure in the marketing pipeline of diamonds.  Diamond jewelry is generally a relatively low turnover business.  But, on the other hand, it’s a business where one must maintain a massive level of inventory.  If you just wanted to keep a stock of 100 loose diamonds for customers to chose from (which, considering all the different shapes and sizes and colors and clarities, 100 really isn’t such a large number), that could easily cost between $500,000 and $1,000,000.  And this is just for the diamonds!  Imagine all the gold and watches.  Most jewelers can’t afford to maintain such a large inventory with their cash alone, so they generally must borrow heavily.  In order to cover this enormous cost, jewelry markups have historically been quite large.  There’s even a vernacular term for the standard markup in the jewelry business of 100% — it’s called a “keystone.”

How Blue Nile Addressed these Issues

blue_nile_logoAs you probably already know, Blue Nile does not inventory any loose diamonds.  All of the loose diamonds listed on their website are all sitting in tens, if not hundreds, of vaults all over the world belonging to just as many different companies.  These companies send Blue Nile a constant electronic feed of their inventory including all details of each diamond along with their wholesale price of the diamond.  Blue Nile adds on a standard markup (usually around 18%) and presents these diamonds to the web-surfing diamond consumer.  When a customer purchases a diamond, the diamond is shipped directly from the supplier to the customer with a standardized invoice from Blue Nile that the supplier is able to print out.  I’m not sure exactly how long it takes Blue Nile to pay the vendor for the sale, but it is almost certainly not longer than 60 days.

From the perspective of the sightholder, listing their diamonds on Blue Nile costs them nothing.  These companies anyway have a constantly high level of inventory.  So as long as the diamond is in their office, all they have to do is upload its details to Blue Nile and it immediately become available for sale.  If the sightholder has a regular customer who wants the diamond, so they sell it to their customer, and simply remove it from their Blue Nile feed.  No opportunities are lost, only new opportunities are achieved.  And since there are no expenses selling diamonds through Blue Nile, the sightholder is motivated to offer lower wholesale prices in their feed upload to Blue Nile.

From Blue Nile’s perspective, they have none of the high inventory carrying costs of your typical bricks-and-mortar jewelry store, so they can survive, and thrive, on a significantly lower profit margin (18% versus 100%).  Also, Blue Nile provides live data to all of its suppliers of how their prices compare to their competitors for similar items.  This creates a true competitive market dynamic that ultimately drives prices down to their minimum.

Blue Nile vs. James Allen

Since Blue Nile came onto the scene, there have been an innumerable amount of imitators.  Just about all of them, however, can’t match Blue Nile’s size of virtual inventory and ease of use and customer service.  In this regard, Blue Nile truly carved out a significant first-mover advantage.

On the other hand, though, Blue Nile’s feature set is set and defined, it is easily replicable.  Their first-mover advantage will never allow them to offer diamonds any cheaper.  In fact, it can only hinder them, since they have a significant marketing budget they need to cover.

One firm stands out as taking all the good that Blue Nile delivered to the industry and bringing it one giant step farther — Jamesallen.com.jamesallen-logo

You see, for all of Blue Nile’s great innovation in how to deliver diamonds to the consumer in the most cost effective way, there was always one giant advantage the bricks-and-mortar stores had over them.  In a store, you could actually see the diamond before you decided to purchase it!  It seems silly and obvious, but it’s truly a major factor.  Not everybody can afford a VS or VVS diamond where seeing the diamond is less important.  Blue Nile tries to make the claim that loose diamonds are a commodity and you can learn all you need to learn about each one by reading its certificate.  Not only is this not true, but most consumers already intuitively understand that it’s not true.  As I explained in my article about clarity, no two VS2s or SI2s, or I1s are alike.  For most diamonds VS2 and lower, you really need to examine the diamond before you buy it.

Jamesallen.com solves this issue with their “virtual loupe.”  Now, you can buy a diamond online and examine it ahead of time.  This not only will give you the peace of mind that you are going to receive what you expect to receive given the clarity you have chose, but now you can purposely look for a lower clarity diamond (that will still look great to the naked eye) because you can check it and see for yourself!

If you have any questions, please leave a comment below and I will usually respond within 24 hours.

Leave a Comment

Please Note: For personal diamond assistance, you will receive a much quicker response sending us an email via the contact form. Comments should be reserved for questions and/or comments about this specific article. Thank you.

302 Comments

  1. Nic     Reply

    Thanks a lot for your wealth of knowledge.

    Does Blue Nile and or James Allen receive lists of diamonds from their suppliers that are less desirable, even though their diamonds are GIA certified. I had a local Jeweler tell me the other day that this is so.

    Maybe a good plan of attack would be to purchase the diamond I want, get it looked at locally and then if I am not happy I could always return it?

    Thanks again

    Nic

    • Mike     Reply

      That is typical salesman BS. JA and BN list the entire inventories from the major wholesalers. This is done virtually (as we mention above). Are there a lot of sub-par diamonds up there? Sure, that is why you need the tools (certificates, high quality photos, advice from experts like us) to select the right diamond. But they also offer far more high ‘value’ diamonds than any jeweler can hope to offer. I don’t know which jeweler you were talking to, but I can tell you how they usually buy diamonds. Someone like Ira or myself would go visit them (and most of the other shops in the city) and we would try to sell them whatever we were carrying. That selection would be a tiny fraction of what our company actually had. And it wouldn’t just be the best selection of the diamonds. We are responsible to sell everything from the top quality to the junk.

  2. Mike     Reply

    They do not. Its actually impossible to do that with a video (as their new photos are actually that).

  3. Ed     Reply

    Hello gents,

    I have just stumbled upon your site whilst researching a particular independent jeweller in the diamond district in New York who has produced some pieces for a family member.

    Is this a good place for a novice to buy an engagement ring? I would be sending the chap a photograph of the style of ring (very simple platinum solitaire with as good a diamond, round or princess, as I can get for around $10000 -$12000) and an idea of the quality of stone I would be looking for.

    Any advice would be very much appreciated.
    Regards
    Ed

    • Mike     Reply

      It would only be a good idea if they are selling you GIA certified (not appraised) diamonds.

  4. Devon     Reply

    Hi Mike, I am a little concerned about buying online. The deals to be had are awesome, but I’m worried about the maintenance on my ring long term. The setting I like is from Blue Nile and it has 148 micropave set diamonds. We’re having James Allen price it out as a custom ring just to explore our options there, but do you think their maintenance program is any better at JA? I’m almost wondering if the web is good for initial sale, but a local jeweler is best for inspections and maintenance when a little diamond goes missing. Any help you can give us would be amazing. I’m looking for J diamonds, Excellent Cut, VS2 or better clarity, and as big a diamond that 10K will buy. Within those parameters, JA and Blue Nile are neck and neck with price.

    • Mike     Reply

      Hi Devon,

      We have had excellent feedback from readers about maintenance with JA. It is incredibly rare that you need work done that costs more than a couple of bucks. Additionally, stores vary just as much as websites when it comes to quality/service. Just because the jeweler exudes ‘relationship’ when he is trying to make the sale, doesn’t mean they will be there when you need something fixed.

Helping you get the most value on your diamond purchase

We are diamond industry veterans who will teach you to identify scams and avoid spending money on features you can’t see.

Click Now for Help

Article Finder

Filter posts on the site that are relevant to your diamond search.

  Returns results

Wondering why we do this? Think we’re biased? You’re only half right. Learn More