Q&A: Ideal Cut Round Diamond for $1500 Budget

The following is a real email conversation between The Diamond Pro and a reader just like you who contacted us. Personal information is always removed. Learn from these posts, or contact us yourself to get free personalized help.

What is this

I will soon be purchasing an engagement ring. Soon, as in the next week or so. I’ve been researching and learning for months though, through bluenile.com, jamesallen.com, and your wonderful website. I feel like a bit of an expert now, but thought I would solicit your advice before I make the final decision. I finally have the money, I’m ready to go, I just want to find the perfect stone now.

Here’s the deal. $1500 is my absolute limit, I know it’s not much, but I want to get the best I can for that price. With the basic ring options on BN and JA, that leaves about $1100 tops for the diamond. My girlfriend and I looked at rings together about a year ago, then put the idea on the back burner because of money issues. She doesn’t know I’ve been secretly saving up this $1500 all year long. She’s a bit of a tomboy, doesn’t wear a lot of jewelry, and when we looked together we were looking at small sizes anyways. I was suprised when she was ”grossed out” by the 1 carat sized diamonds and quickly passed them off as too gaudy (lucky me!). She was happy with a .33 carat, but I could really tell she liked the half carat a lot. So, that’s my goal, a .45-.50 carat diamond. But the most important part is the sparkle, the stones we were looking at really sparkled and she couldn’t take her eyes off of it, no matter the size.

So, here I am, diamond shopping online. I’ve found what I’m looking for, in terms of size and what-I-think-will-sparkle expectations. Examples:

BN: .46, Ideal Cut, H, VVS2 for $1030

BN: .47, Ideal Cut, I, VS1 for $978

BN: .46, Ideal Cut, G, VVS2 for $1060

J

.44, Ideal Cut, G, VVS2 for $1090

JA: .43, Ideal Cut, H, VVS2 for $990

And so on…you can tell from those 5 listings that I’m looking for something that’s Ideal, I color or better, VS1 or better, and as close to .50 carats as I can get. Is this a resonable expectation? Am I going at this wrong? Should I consider a J color or a lower inclusion rating?

Also, I’m no gemologist, so what should I be looking for in JA’s diamond pictures? How can I tell if it’s cloudy or if the inclusions are too large? I want a nice looking diamond, but I want it to have lasting value, too.

Oh last thing: white gold ring. Must be white gold.

Thank you!!

Thanks for writing. Is there any particular reason you’re limiting yourself to VS1+? Have you read my article on clarity? If not, go have a look:

http://www.diamonds.pro/truth-about/diamond-clarity/

I think this is a MUCH better option than any of those you selected:

http://www.jamesallen.com/diamonds/G-SI2-Ideal-Cut-Round-Diamond-1338434.asp

It’s much bigger. Totally eye clean. AGS triple zero ideal cut. Same price basically as the others. Just as brilliant. Just as white. But a lot bigger.

Let me know what you think!

Thanks for getting back to me so quickly, I really appreciate it. I’ve now read your article on clarity, and I totally see where you’re coming from on that point. Now I’m looking on James Allen at the choice you suggested and others like it. I guess I was just scared of ordering a diamond that I’ve never seen before and getting one with a dreaded “black spot” on it. Too much shopping on Blue Nile I guess.

I think I’ll be sticking to James Allen now. Unfortunately, a lot of the ones I’m looking at right now don’t have a picture uploaded online, but I’m requesting them individually. I’m no expert, so another apprehension I have is that I can’t really be sure what to look for in the virtual loupe. Any tips? I’m looking for the black specks, but are there any other things I should be aware of that will be noticable by the naked eye?

Thanks again

It’d be hard to tell you what to look for. It’s not an exact science. It comes from years of experience looking at thousands upon thousands of diamonds to get a real feel for what kind of inclusion will be clean to the naked eye and what won’t be. But I really do believe that the other stone I recommended is a fantastic option for you. If you have any questions about other stones, just send me the links, and I’ll be happy to take a look for you.
Just wanted to say thank you. I jumped on the diamond you suggested for me. I used the chat feature on the james allen website, and they were also able to confirm that the diamond is eye clean (not that I didn’t believe you, but two heads are better than one!). I get regular email offers from blue nile, so I knew that they were currently offering a New Year’s $100 discount, and I mentioned it to them and they matched it! So I got the diamond and saved $100! Pretty great stone for only $920!

So, thanks to you, I have a sparkling new diamond being set and it’s a tenth of a carat bigger than I ever dreamed it could be! That extra little bit…well, not so little, it’s a 25% increase to the size…is thanks to you and I’ll never forget it! As soon as I propose (in about 2 weeks), I’ll spread the word of your website and your advice to everyone I know!

Thank you, sir!

Great to hear! So glad you got the discount! PLEASE let me know what you think when it arrives!

Leave a Comment

Please Note: For personal diamond assistance, you will receive a much quicker response sending us an email via the contact form. Comments should be reserved for questions and/or comments about this specific article. Thank you.

4 Comments

  1. Brandon     Reply

    Hi,
    I am in the same boat as the previous writers. Looking for a diamond 1/3 – 1/2 carat with a super simple setting. $1300-1500 max. She is petit and wouldn’t love a huge ring but sparkly would nice. I am doing this without much input from her because I want to surprise her on an upcoming trip. I like the round cut but I also like the Princess cut and that seems to be a better bang for buck . I checked out the articles on clarity and that doesn’t seem to be a huge worry with the right cut.

    Thanks in advance for any recommendations.

    Best,
    Brandon

  2. Rob     Reply

    hi,

    I am looking for an engagement ring. I was reading the other posts and would like to have your opinion on this diamond i am looking at, it would be much appreciated.

    http://www.jamesallen.com/diamonds/H-VS1-Good-Cut-Round-Diamond-1393278.asp

    my budget is 1500$ as the above.

    thanks!

    • Ira Weissman     Reply

      Hey Rob. That stone looks nice. If you can find one with an “Excellent” cut grade, it might be better, but for the money, this is a nice choice.

Helping you get the most value on your diamond purchase

We are diamond industry veterans who will teach you to identify scams and avoid spending money on features you can’t see.

Click Now for Help

Article Finder

Filter posts on the site that are relevant to your diamond search.

  Returns results

Wondering why we do this? Think we’re biased? You’re only half right. Learn More